Lessons From the West Coast: Why a Tax on Savings Failed

An added tax on high net worth just failed in California. That hasn’t stopped unions and other tax hike advocates –  including the Mass. Budget and Policy Center – from pushing a similar idea in Massachusetts.

California’s Proposition 40 – which would have taxed assets such as savings, investments, property, and company ownership – was resoundingly rejected by voters on November 3. It wasn’t just wealthy residents who voted it down: 49 of the Golden State’s 58 counties disapproved.

Some of the loudest critics weren’t the rich – they were residents from rural and blue-collar areas such as Modoc, Del Norte, and Sierra Counties. Several of the state’s most-influential labor unions lined up in opposition to the measure, too. And while Proposition 40 failed, voters passed an opposing measure (Proposition 42) that prohibits futures taxes on savings and investments. Advocates for hiking Massachusetts’ taxes have hinted at bringing a similar proposal to the Bay State. 

Policymakers and voters should learn from California’s experience, where a bipartisan group of voters agree more taxes on savings won’t help residents or the state.

A Sure Way To Drive Out Taxpayers

Just the spectre of a new tax on savings and assets pushed high earners out of California. A Hoover Institution study by Stanford economists found several billionaires left the Golden State after the proposal was filed – accounting for roughly $540 billion in net worth, nearly 30% of California’s total billionaire net worth. Among them was Google co-founder Sergey Brin, who joined his counterpart Larry Page in Miami and since expanded Google’s South Florida headquarters.

Massachusetts can hardly afford such a consequence. The Commonwealth has already experienced years of net outmigration, particularly to lower-cost, lower-tax states like Florida, New Hampshire, and North Carolina. New data shows that in the first two years after the state’s surtax on income over $1 million went into effect, we saw a net loss of 60,000 residents, and $7.8 billion in adjusted gross income.

Higher earners are even more mobile than the overall population. For example, Massachusetts reached its peak number of million-dollar earners in 2021. Then the state passed a surtax on that income over $1 million in 2022. The following year, the number of million-dollar taxpayers dropped 13.5%. Compare that to Florida, where the number of taxpayers earning $1 million grew. 

A burdensome tax structure doesn’t just hurt high earners. It discourages business investment, which means fewer jobs for local residents and lower community investment.

Taxing Savings Won’t Live Up to Revenue Promises

Introducing a tax on high earners also erodes a substantial portion of the tax base, leaving residents who can’t easily move footing the bill for state spending.

While billion-dollar earners make up roughly 1% of all California taxpayers, they pay roughly a quarter of all taxes collected by the state, according to a recent Pacific Research Institute analysis. When high-earning residents leave, that tax base leaves with them.

The Stanford University/Hoover Institution analysis found if California’s Proposition 40 went into place, it would have taken in less than one-third of what it was projected to raise in revenue, and would have ended up costing the state tax revenue for years to come. California’s billion-dollar earners also pay as much as $5.8 billion every year in state income taxes, which would be lost if those taxpayers decide to move out. 

As a result, the authors conclude the tax would most likely have a net negative impact on California’s state finances, rather than fulfilling proponents’ promise of raising revenue to fund state programs.

It Won’t Stop at High Earners

After seeing the push-back the policy received in California, tax hike advocates are looking for a number that might gain traction among the Commonwealth’s voters. Recently, Phineas Baxandall from MassBudget suggested $100 million instead of $1 billion. In its laundry list of tax hike recommendations, MassBudget even proposes a similar tax on all assets over $50 million, “regardless of whether or not [they have] generated any income.”

These may still sound like big numbers, but this policy won’t just target high earners. A tax on the savings residents have built up over time – including their investments and other assets – doesn’t look at income alone. As a result, even taxpayers with moderate income levels could be subject to this tax – one they might not have the ability to pay based on their existing cash flow.  

Out in Washington, where taxpayers are subject to a 9.9% tax on income over $1 million, lawmakers are also dropping the act proposals like these are only intended for wealthy residents. State Rep. Cindy Ryu claimed the threshold for the tax should be lowered to however much you need to live on in Washington, which she proposed was roughly $250,000 a year. 

But no “magic number” will make this policy work for Massachusetts. Our taxpayers are already wary of the state’s top-five tax burdens – increasing these costs would only spell disaster for our economic future. 

Conclusion

Bringing a California-style tax on Massachusetts’ high earners would be a lose-lose for the Bay State. It would make it harder for higher-earning entrepreneurs and job creators to live and do business here, decimating job opportunities and hurting the state’s emerging industries. It would also drive more taxpayers out of the state, exacerbating the existing outmigration crisis, and gutting the tax base that funds key state programs and services.

California voters saw the writing on the wall this election. Not only did they reject the ill-fated tax on high net worth individuals, they also passed a prohibition on new taxes that target savings, such as retirement, individually-owned assets, and other personal savings. Middle class voters understood that driving out high earners would backfire, leaving the burden to pay for state spending on everyone else.

Massachusetts’ policymakers should take note before pushing an idea even California didn’t want.